Missing Shingles and Wind Damage: Repair or Replace?

A few shingles lost on a sound roof is a repair. Shingles coming off in more than one place, or on a roof that was already worn, is a sign the whole roof is letting go.

An old green house under pine trees whose roof has missing and broken shingles, patches and needle debris caught in the gaps
Fig. 01 Missing and broken shingles, with debris caught where they used to be

What you may notice

  • Shingles or torn tabs on the lawn or in the gutters after a windy night

  • A rectangle on the roof that is darker or a different color than the shingles around it

  • Tabs that flap in a breeze, or stand up and do not lie back down

  • A horizontal crease across a shingle where it has been bent back

  • Exposed black underlayment, bare wood or a row of nail heads

How soon it needs attention

If you can see underlayment or wood, get it covered soon. Underlayment is a backup layer, not a roof, and it will not last through a wet season exposed. If tabs are creased or lifted but still in place, the roof will shed water for now, but each wind event will take more. Either way, do not go up to check; a roofer can judge it from a ladder and photos.

Missing shingles: what the pattern tells you

Missing shingles are the most visible kind of roof damage, and where they came from says a lot. A single patch near a ridge or an edge, on the side that faces the wind, is ordinary storm damage. Tabs gone here and there across more than one slope suggest the shingles have stopped sealing to each other.

On the east side of the metro, and across the river in Vancouver, the cause is often the winter wind that pours out of the Columbia River Gorge.

After a windstorm or ice storm

The Portland area has two kinds of storm that strip and break shingles. East wind pours out of the Columbia River Gorge in winter: in January 2024 the National Weather Service recorded gusts to 55 mph in northern Gresham and nearby cities (the Gresham page has the detail), and 40 to 55 mph across the Portland and Vancouver metro (see the Vancouver page). Ice is the other: in February 2021 the heaviest ice fell in a band starting around Oregon City, and ice brings limbs down onto roofs.

After either:

  • Look from the ground and from upstairs windows. Shingles in the yard, tabs standing up, a patch of a different color, or a branch on the roof are all reasons to have a roofer look.
  • Photograph the damage and any debris before cleanup, for your insurer.
  • Do not climb up. Wet or icy shingles and a damaged deck are how people get hurt.
  • Ask for a free roof inspection. Creased shingles that are still in place are easy to miss from the ground and fail in the next storm.

What a roofer checks

  • whether the shingles around the gap are still sealed down
  • whether creased tabs nearby are cracked through
  • the underlayment and deck where they were exposed
  • ridge caps, which take the most wind
  • the age and overall condition of the roof

A bare patch can let water in before you see a stain. If one has appeared, the roof leak page covers what to do indoors.

Repair or replace?

Replacing a handful of shingles is a routine roof repair. When the same roof keeps losing them, the money is better put toward a replacement. The cost page lists published ranges for both.

What causes it

Shingles are held by nails and by a strip of sealant that bonds each course to the one below. When that bond has aged out or never set, wind lifts the tab, creases it and eventually tears it off, leaving underlayment or nail heads exposed.

  • The sealant strip between courses has aged and no longer holds the tab down

  • Shingles installed in cold weather that never bonded

  • Nails placed too high, so they miss the layer below

  • Old shingles that have gone brittle and tear at the nail

  • Limbs striking or scraping the roof in a storm

Request a Roofing Quote

Tell us about your roof and we will follow up to set up a free roof inspection and a written quote.

Common questions

Can a roofer replace just the missing shingles?

Yes, when the surrounding shingles are flexible enough to lift without cracking. New shingles are slid in, nailed and sealed by hand. On an old, brittle roof the neighbors break as they are lifted, and the repair grows.

Will the new shingles match?

Rarely exactly. The roof has weathered, and the product or color may no longer be made. A roofer can get close, and can put the patch where it shows least if there is a choice.

Does insurance cover shingles blown off by wind?

Wind damage is the kind of sudden loss policies are generally written for, but coverage and deductibles vary and insurers look at the roof's age and condition. Ask your insurer, and photograph the damage and the debris before anything is cleaned up.

Is one missing shingle a problem?

It is a small problem that grows. If underlayment, nail heads or bare wood show through the gap, water can reach the deck in the next long rain, and the shingles around it are now exposed to wind from underneath. It is usually a quick repair if it is done before the wet season.

How long do I have to file an insurance claim after a storm?

That depends on your policy, so read it or ask your insurer as soon as you can after the storm. Photograph the damage and any debris before cleanup, keep the photos, and report it promptly.

How many missing shingles means a new roof?

There is no count. One patch on one slope after an unusual storm is a repair. Losses on several slopes, or again after an ordinary storm, mean the sealant has failed across the roof.

Request a Roofing Quote

Tell us about your roof and we will follow up to set up a free roof inspection and a written quote.