Architectural shingles are two or more layers of asphalt shingle bonded together, which makes them thicker, heavier and shadowed; 3-tab shingles are a single flat layer cut into three equal tabs. On a Portland-area reroof today, architectural is the usual choice and often the only one a manufacturer offers: Malarkey, the shingle maker based in Portland, lists no 3-tab line. Both kinds can meet Oregon’s wind rule at the metro’s design wind speed, so the real differences are in looks, weight, the wind warranty, and how well a future repair will match. This guide sets out each one, with the code and manufacturer sources checked on October 29, 2026.

What is the difference between architectural and 3-tab shingles?

Both are asphalt shingles with a fiberglass mat, both are sold in bundles that cover a “square” of 100 square feet, and both go on the same kind of solid deck. The home inspectors’ association InterNACHI, in its guide to asphalt shingles, describes the two this way:

3-tab (strip) shingles Architectural (laminated, dimensional) shingles
How it is made One layer, with two cutouts that divide the exposed edge into three tabs Two or more layers bonded together; the upper layers are smaller and cut into shapes
How the roof looks Flat and regular, with even lines of tabs Irregular and shadowed, sometimes made to resemble wood shakes
Typical weight per square 200 to 250 pounds 250 to 300 pounds; some premium versions with up to five layers approach 500
Typical size Usually about 12 by 36 inches Metric sizing, about 13 by 39 inches
Wind resistance InterNACHI describes Designed for winds up to about 60 mph 70 to 110 mph maximum

Those are InterNACHI’s typical figures across the market, not a rating for any one product; the product’s own data sheet is what counts. Malarkey’s Vista, for example, an architectural shingle, measures 13-1/4 by 38-7/8 inches with a 5-5/8 inch exposure, 66 shingles and three bundles to the square. Oregon’s code requires every asphalt shingle to meet ASTM D3462, the standard for shingles made on a glass-fiber mat, whichever style it is. In the Portland trade both kinds are usually called composition or “comp” roofing.

The weight column matters more than it looks. It bears on how a heavier shingle fits Oregon’s permit exemption, covered further down.

Are 3-tab shingles still made?

Yes, but in fewer lines than before, and not by every maker. Owens Corning still publishes a product page for its Supreme 3-tab shingles. Malarkey, which gives a Portland mailing address, lists four shingle lines on its shingles page: Highlander, Vista and Legacy (all architectural) and Windsor (a designer shingle). There is no 3-tab among them.

What that means for you:

  • A full reroof will almost always be quoted in an architectural shingle, and comparing bids is easier if every roofer names the product line.
  • A repair on an old 3-tab roof is where availability bites. A patch needs a shingle of the same size and shape, and a weathered roof rarely matches a new bundle anyway. The missing shingles page covers what a roofer can do when the match is poor.
  • A garage, shed or small outbuilding is where a 3-tab still makes sense to some owners, if the roofer can source one and the look does not matter.

Which shingles meet Oregon’s wind rule?

Oregon’s residential code does not pick a style. It asks for a tested wind classification on every asphalt shingle. Section R905.2.4.1 of the Oregon Residential Specialty Code requires shingles tested to ASTM D7158 (or to ASTM D3161 when a product falls outside D7158’s scope), with the classification printed on the package. Its Table R905.2.4.1 then sets the minimum class by the site’s basic design wind speed. At up to 110 mph, the lowest row, the code accepts D7158 Class D, G or H, or D3161 Class A, D or F.

The metro sits in that lowest row. Table R301.2 of the same code, in chapter 3, lists a basic design wind speed of 98 mph for Multnomah and Clackamas counties and 97 mph for Washington County. The code also maps special wind regions in Figure R301.2.1(1) and says sites on their edges are verified with the ASCE 7 hazard tool, so a house in or beside one of those regions is checked site by site. Outside them, the wind-class test is met by a shingle with any of the classes in that lowest row, 3-tab or architectural.

These sections are quoted from the 2023 edition. The Building Codes Division’s adoption page says the 2026 edition’s construction chapters took effect on October 1, 2026 with a six-month phase-in, becoming mandatory on April 1, 2027, and that the integrated 2026 text is still being published, so until then either edition may be used outside Chapter 1.

That moves the real comparison to the product sheet. Malarkey’s Vista, for instance, lists ASTM D3161 Class F and ASTM D7158 Class H, with a standard wind warranty to 110 mph and an enhanced one to 130 mph. Wind warranties come with installation conditions set by the maker, so ask which ones apply to the product in your bid. On the east side of the metro, where winter wind pours out of the Columbia River Gorge, this is the line to read closely; the Gresham page has the National Weather Service figures from January 2024.

Roof pitch, nails and underlayment

The installation rules are the same for both styles, and they are worth knowing because they show up as line items:

  1. Minimum pitch. Asphalt shingles may be used only on slopes of 2 in 12 or steeper (R905.2.2). From 2 in 12 up to 4 in 12 the code calls for a double layer of underlayment (R905.1.1). Anything flatter needs a low-slope membrane; see flat roofing.
  2. Nail count. At least four fasteners per strip shingle, or two per individual shingle, and more where the manufacturer asks for more (R905.2.6).
  3. Nail type. Galvanized steel, stainless steel, aluminum or copper roofing nails with at least a 12-gauge shank and a 3/8-inch head, long enough to go 3/4 inch into the sheathing or right through it (R905.2.5).
  4. Nail placement. Laminated shingles carry a printed nailing area; on Vista it is 1-5/16 inches tall. The maker’s instructions govern where the nails go and how many a high-wind installation needs.

How weight affects the permit question

Since October 1, 2026, Chapter 1 of the 2026 Oregon Residential Specialty Code exempts reroofing, including replacement of damaged sheathing, where the increased dead load is 4 pounds per square foot or less, with exceptions for townhouses, building-integrated solar roofing and houses built under a locally adopted wildfire code. The roof permit guide quotes it in full. Four pounds per square foot is 400 pounds per square, so InterNACHI’s typical weights translate like this:

Job Typical weight change per square Against the 400 lb line
Tear off 3-tab, install architectural Roughly 0 to 100 lb more Well under it
Tear off architectural, install architectural About the same Well under it
Recover: architectural over one existing layer The whole new layer, 250 to 300 lb Under it
Recover with a premium shingle near 500 lb About 500 lb Over it

This is arithmetic from typical figures, not a ruling: the building department decides how it measures the increase on your house. Two cautions go with it. A recover is allowed only over a single existing layer that is sound and dry (R908.3.1.1), so the roof replacement page explains why a tear-off is usually the better job anyway. And the City of Portland’s own permit page, last updated May 20, 2026 and checked October 29, 2026, still uses the older wording: reroofing “with a roofing material of similar weight” needs no building permit, while reroofing a dwelling in a Wildfire Zone or a townhouse does. Gresham’s and Lake Oswego’s own pages, as quoted in the permit guide (checked October 7, 2026), list a full tear-off with new sheathing as permit work. Ask for the product’s weight per square on the bid, and confirm with your city.

Algae streaks, moss and a shaded roof

Dark streaks on a shingle roof are usually algae, not dirt. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association’s page on algae discoloration names Gloeocapsa magma as the most common species, describes the stain as brown to black, and says it is most widespread in the Gulf States and along the Northwest and Eastern seaboards. Its answer is algae-resistant (AR) shingles, which it describes as designed to inhibit algae growth for extended periods. Both styles come in AR versions; Malarkey’s Highlander AR, for example, has granules that help reduce algae streaks, and the company describes Windsor as its highest algae protection.

Moss is a different organism and a different problem, and ARMA says the two should not be confused. Oregon State University Extension, in its roof moss article, calls moss inevitable in the moist Pacific Northwest, notes that it depends on shade, and warns that on asphalt roofs it can lift shingles and let water reach the layers beneath. An AR label is a claim about algae, not moss. Malarkey’s Highlander page spells it out: its algae warranty applies only to blue-green algae (Gloeocapsa magma) and excludes moss, lichens and other growth, and two of its colors made in California have no copper granules and no algae coverage. So read the color as well as the product line, and on a roof under firs and maples, keep watching for moss whatever the label says.

Fire and impact ratings

Fire resistance is classed A, B or C under ASTM E108 or UL 790, with Class A the highest, and the class is printed on the data sheet; Malarkey’s Vista and Highlander both list ASTM E108 Class A, for example. Oregon’s code (R902.1) requires classified roofing where a jurisdiction designates it by law and wherever the edge of the roof is less than 3 feet from a lot line, which is worth checking on a narrow city lot. The City of Portland also requires a permit to reroof a dwelling in one of its Wildfire Zones, and the permit guide explains those zones.

Impact ratings are the other line on many data sheets. Malarkey lists a UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating, the highest class, for Vista, Legacy and Windsor, and Class 3 for Highlander. If an impact rating would change your insurance premium, ask your insurer before choosing.

Which lasts longer?

InterNACHI’s life expectancy chart gives 20 years for 3-tab asphalt shingles and 30 for architectural, and adds that a roof’s life depends on local weather, design, material quality and maintenance. Those are national estimates. Our guide to how long a roof lasts in Portland sets them beside the rain, shade and wind that shorten them here, and explains why the years printed on a warranty are not a lifespan.

Do architectural shingles cost more?

Yes, per square: 3-tab is the least expensive asphalt shingle, and architectural sits above it. This guide publishes no prices. The roof replacement cost page does, each with its source and date, and the Portland-area whole-roof ranges it takes from local roofers are for architectural shingles with a full tear-off. If a bid comes in far below them, check whether it names a 3-tab product, a recover instead of a tear-off, or leaves something out.

Choosing shingles for a Portland roof

For most houses the decision comes down to a short list:

  • Pick architectural unless there is a reason not to. It is the only style the Portland maker lists, the basis of the local cost ranges, and the one InterNACHI credits with the higher wind resistance.
  • Choose an AR version if the roof is shaded or faces north, and treat moss as a separate maintenance matter.
  • Check the wind class and wind warranty on the data sheet, especially on an exposed east-side or hilltop lot.
  • Keep the weight in mind if anyone suggests a recover or a heavy designer shingle, and ask what that does to the permit answer.
  • Think about repairs. Ask how widely the product line is stocked, since a future patch needs a shingle of the same size and shape.
  • Check local design rules. In Oregon City’s historic districts the City’s Historic Review Board policy lists both 3-tab and architectural composition as allowed; the Oregon City page has the detail.

In Vancouver, Washington the shingle choice is the same, but the permit rules are Washington’s; the Vancouver page covers them.

What should a shingle bid say?

  • The manufacturer and the product line, not just “architectural shingles”
  • The wind classification (ASTM D3161 or D7158 class) and the wind warranty the product carries as installed
  • Whether it is AR, and the fire class
  • The weight per square, if the job is a recover
  • The nail count per shingle, and the underlayment on any slope under 4 in 12
  • Starter, hip and ridge products from the same line
  • Whether it is a tear-off or a recover, and why

The roof replacement page lists the rest of a full bid, and the metal roofing page covers the main alternative to asphalt. To have someone look at the roof before you choose, request a free roof inspection, and check any contractor’s license with the Oregon Construction Contractors Board (or Washington L&I in Vancouver) before you sign.